Comparing MSPs?

How do you compare MSPs? With a framework, not a sales pitch.

Score every provider on the same weighted criteria (response and resolution terms, engineering depth on your platforms, coverage, reporting, security scope and exit terms) and make them answer in writing. The kit below gives you the criteria, the questions to ask, an RFP outline and a scoring matrix you can use with any provider, including us.

  • US-based 24x7x365 NOC & SOC
  • 15-minute P1 response
  • WBENC-certified WBE
What you get
  1. 1A weighted scoring matrix (CSV, opens in Excel)
  2. 2The questions to ask before you switch
  3. 3An RFP outline and an SLA and contract checklist

No sales call needed to see your result.

US-based NOC & SOC, no offshore first tier
24x7x365
P1 response on every managed tier
15 min
Engineering certifications across all vendors
100+
Sites deployed and managed
2,400+
WBENC-certified Woman-Owned Business Enterprise
WBE

Fortinet Platinum Partner · Cloudflare Elite Partner · Cisco Premier Partner · Arista Elite Partner

The kit

Everything you need to compare MSPs on the same terms

A designed PDF and an editable scoring matrix. Use it with any provider, including us.

  1. 01
    How to compare MSPs
    The six criteria, how to weight them, and the red flags for each.
  2. 02
    Questions to ask before you switch
    Forty questions by category, with what a good answer sounds like.
  3. 03
    RFP outline
    The sections an MSP RFP needs, and what to ask for in each.
  4. 04
    SLA and contract checklist
    Response, resolution, credits, reporting, renewal and exit terms.
  5. 05
    Transition and exit checklist
    How to change providers without an unmonitored day.
  6. 06
    Weighted scoring matrix
    Editable CSV: weights, scores and totals for up to four providers.
MSP RFP & Evaluation Kit
PDF guide + editable scoring matrix

Downloads straight away. Use it with any provider, including us. No newsletter, never shared.

What to weigh

The six criteria that separate MSPs

Weight them to your situation, but score every provider on all six, in writing.

Response and resolution
What to ask forWritten P1 response and resolution targets by priority, measured and reported, with credits when missed.
Red flag"Best effort", or response targets with no resolution commitment.
Engineering depth
What to ask forSenior engineers certified on the platforms you actually run, reachable without a tier-1 queue.
Red flagEscalations that end with you calling the vendor yourself.
Coverage model
What to ask forOne 24x7x365 team with the same terms at night and at weekends.
Red flagAn answering service after hours, or an offshore first tier that only collects details.
Visibility
What to ask forA live view of devices, lifecycle dates, risks and SLA performance, plus trend reviews.
Red flagA monthly ticket count and nothing else.
Security
What to ask forClear SOC / MDR scope: what is monitored, who investigates, who contains, how fast.
Red flagSecurity described only as "we install antivirus".
Exit terms
What to ask forYou own documentation, configurations and credentials, with a defined handover.
Red flagSilent auto-renewal and no handover clause.
Start here

Grade your current provider first.

Twelve questions, about three minutes, an instant A–F grade. It shows which of the criteria matter most in your situation before you write the RFP.

  • Responsiveness, proactivity and visibility
  • Expertise and accountability
  • Contract and exit terms
Responsiveness1 / 12
When something business-critical breaks, how fast is a qualified engineer actually working on it?
Test our response time

Response is easy to promise. Ours is in writing.

Every managed tier carries a 15-minute P1 response, answered by engineers in a US-based 24x7x365 NOC and SOC. Test it before you sign: call us, or run us alongside your current provider for 30 days.

About the 30-day shadow pilot
P1 response
15 minutes
Every managed tier
P1 resolution target
4 hours
Advantage tier
Coverage
24x7x365
US-based NOC and SOC
First line
Engineers
No offshore first tier
Outcome SLAs
Contractual
Complete tier
When an MSP stopped answering

15 minutes from call to senior engineering leadership mobilised, for a regional gaming and hospitality operator whose incumbent MSP was unresponsive. Operations were restored by 2:15 AM.

Read the case study
Straight answers

What people ask us next

What should an MSP RFP include?

Your environment (sites, devices, users, platforms), the services in scope, required response and resolution targets by priority, reporting expectations, security responsibilities, transition and exit requirements, and how you will score responses. The kit includes an outline with each section.

What questions should I ask an MSP before switching?

Ask who answers at 2 a.m., how P1 response and resolution are measured and credited, which engineers are certified on your platforms, what reporting you will see, how they take over an environment someone else built, and what you get back if you leave. The kit lists the full set by category.

How should we weight the criteria?

Weight what has hurt you. Teams leaving an unresponsive provider usually put response, resolution and coverage first; teams with security gaps weight SOC scope higher. The scoring matrix has default weights you can change.

Will you take over an environment another provider built?

Yes, and it is a common starting point. Onboarding begins with discovery and documentation of the existing estate, because taking operational responsibility for infrastructure nobody has mapped is how providers inherit problems they cannot then explain.

What does a managed NOC/SOC from BlackHawk Data cost?

BlackHawk Data publishes its annual contract value bands rather than quoting only on request. Essentials (24x7 NOC monitoring and incident response) runs $120K to $400K a year on a per-device or per-site flat fee; Advantage, which adds SOC, MDR and lifecycle management, runs $300K to $1.2M on a per-user blended rate; Complete, which adds roadmap advisory, architecture and vCISO / vCIO, is outcome-based from $1M a year. Tool licenses are included. Final pricing depends on estate size and scope.

Prefer to talk it through?

Twenty minutes with a senior engineer, not a sales rep. Bring your numbers, your contract or your questions.

Or call (877) 456-4295